Danielle R. Gartner, Ceco Maples, Madeline Nash and Heather Howard-Bobiwash. 2023. "Misracialization of Indigenous People in Population Health and Mortality Studies: A Scoping Review to Establish Promising Practices." Epidemiologic Reviews https://doi.org/10.1093/epirev/mxad001
Indigenous people are often misracialized or misclassified as other racial or ethnic identities in population health research. This misclassification leads to underestimation of Indigenous-specific mortality and health metrics, and subsequently, inadequate resource allocation. In recognition of this problem, investigators around the world have devised analytic methods to address racial misclassification of Indigenous people. We carried out a scoping review based on searches in PubMed, Web of Science, and the Native Health Database for empirical studies published after 2000 that include Indigenous-specific estimates of health or mortality and that take analytic steps to rectify racial misclassification of Indigenous people. We then considered the weaknesses and strengths of implemented analytic approaches, with a focus on methods used in the United States (U.S.) context. To do this, we extracted information from 97 articles and compared the analytic approaches used. The most common approach to address Indigenous misclassification is to use data linkage, though other methods include geographic restriction to areas where misclassification is less common, exclusion of some subgroups, imputation, aggregation, and electronic health record abstraction. We identified four primary limitations of these approaches: (1) combining data sources that use inconsistent process and/or sources of race and ethnicity information, (2) conflating race, ethnicity, and nationality, (3) applying insufficient algorithms to bridge, impute, or link race and ethnicity information, and (4) assuming the hyperlocality of Indigenous people. While there is no perfect solution to the issue of Indigenous misclassification in population-based studies, a review of this literature provided promising practices to consider.
Keywords: American Indian/Alaska Native; Classification; Health; Indigenous; Misclassification; Morbidity; Mortality; Native American.